11 Best Sellers for January

For someone who cried about math every day from about 3rd to 8th grade (sorry, Mom!), I sure do love looking at the data for Everyday Reading!

And one of my favorite things? Seeing what you loved most!

Here are the most popular items I shared in January!

Lifelines Flowart
When these were featured in our $10 Gift Guide at Christmas, I didn’t expect them to become such a hit, but they absolutely have been. So many of you have loved them, and after buying several for my own girls, I can confirm they’re just as popular at our house. They’re similar to diamond art, but without the tiny pieces, and I love that each set includes everything you need, making them perfect for easy, grab-and-go entertainment on trips.

Beside the Sea Puzzle
This 500 piece puzzle went WILD. I did it a few years ago and I think in January we’re all dreaming of a seaside vacation! Galison is one of my favorite puzzle brands, and this one also earned a spot on my blog post about the best puzzles you’ve done in 2025.

Magic Puzzles
If you haven’t done a Magic Puzzle yet, you’re truly missing out, they’re some of the most fun and most interesting puzzles I’ve ever worked on. They were wildly popular during the holidays and just as popular this month! (If you’ve been wondering how they work, I show the thing that makes them so cool here.)

EBY Bra
After a bout of jet-lag-fueled frustration with my (very expensive!) uncomfortable bras, I started trying new brands and discovered the EBY support bralette (then promptly donated all my old ones). I now rotate between the support bralette (light, no clasp, my teen girls wear them too) and the Relief Bra for a little more structure with a traditional clasp.

Flip 7
Every year we give a game as a family Christmas gift, and this one has been a total hit! We’ve played it nonstop since winter break, and the best part? It’s under $8. Such a great, budget-friendly gift to share with family and friends.

Walmart Jeans
I love my Spanx jeans (though at $168, they’re definitely an investment), but these Walmart jeans are the budget-friendly look-alike that are so cute, super comfy, and only $25! I own and love both pairs!

Creatine Gummies
These were one of my husband’s favorite products of 2025, and I was surprised to see how many of you were also hunting for creatine gummies! He loved these so much that after finishing the jar, he tried a highly-rated alternative…only to find it terrible. He returned it immediately and went back to these, which he now looks forward to every single day.

Blooming Streets Puzzle
This must be the month of puzzles! January feels like the perfect time to slow down and pull out a puzzle, and since one of my 2026 goals is to do a puzzle every day, I’m happy to be in such good company with all the other puzzlers out there. I worked on this one at my mom’s house and it was so gorgeous. I love all the pink, and it would be perfect for Valentine’s Day too.

Old Navy Wide Leg Jeans
My 15-year-old is in that tricky stage between kids’ and women’s sizing, and these wide-leg jeans from Old Navy were an instant success. She loves them, they’re adorable, and I’ve had tons of messages from women saying they’re their favorite too. And at under $20, they’re such a great find.

Piles Game
I mentioned the game we got for Christmas and my inbox immediately filled with “Have you tried Piles yet?!” messages, plus tons more people saying it was their favorite gift. After dozens of recommendations, I finally ordered it… and you were 100% right. It’s a blast!

Lion Pendant Necklace
It’s clear I’m among fellow Emma M. Lion fans, so many of you picked up these lion pendant necklaces this month. If you’ve read or listened to the book, you know why they’re such a perfect nod to the story. I loved them so much I even bought one for each of my girls for Valentine’s Day this year!

If you bought one of these items (or something else I shared this month!), I’d love to know how you’re liking it!

If you liked this post about the January best sellers, you might also like these other posts: